Career advice services need national policy framework

The authors of Local Variations, a study of the new arrangements for Connexions, careers services and information, advice and guidance services for young people in England, say policy initiatives in the field are "built on sand".

The report examined what had happened to services since responsibility passed to local authorities in April last year. It found that 30 per cent of councils had taken services in-house, while the remainder either left provision with the old Connexions partnership or contracted to another provider.

It argues that where local authorities have taken over Connexions services it is increasingly difficult to identify information, advice and guidance provision from within broader youth support. "The loss of identity and accountability is, in our view, a matter of grave public concern," the report says.

Tony McAleavy, director of education at the CfBT Education Trust, which published the report, said: "It indicates a significant degree of inconsistency in the provision of career guidance to young people. At the time when, because of the downturn, there has never been a greater need for kids to be given the right kind of advice and guidance about higher education and the world of work."

The report also that found that just 40 per cent young people in England receive an interview with a Connexions personal adviser.

"There is a postcode lottery in the extent, nature and quality of the services for young people," said Denise Bertuchi, assistant national officer for education and children's services with Unison.