Other

Opinion: Debate - Should childcarers' references be keptconfidential?

1 min read
A nursery nurse has won a battle with a previous employer to see her reference by approaching the Information Commissioner. However some fear it could stop managers giving their honest opinions, putting children at risk.

YES - Ben Black, director, Tinies Nanny Agency

The childcare recruitment industry relies on people being able to speakfreely about former employees. Anything that restricts that abilityshould be resisted. The consequences of the wrong childcarer ending upin the wrong job do not bear thinking about. The InformationCommissioner was, ultimately, quite receptive about the special needs ofthe childcare market and we are happy that we can treat each case on itsmerits. It was a great test case for us and I am please that it'sresolved.

NO - Tricia Pritchard, senior professional officer, ProfessionalAssociation of Nursery Nurses

The alternative is to allow them to say whatever they wish without riskof challenge. Good employers make employees aware of any shortcomingsthrough appraisals, disciplinary procedures and exit interviews so thata reference includes no surprises. Employees must be allowed to see whatis being said about their suitability. Undeserved, bad references canresult in good childcarers being lost to the already stretchedprofession.

Register Now to Continue Reading

Thank you for visiting Children & Young People Now and making use of our archive of more than 60,000 expert features, topics hubs, case studies and policy updates. Why not register today and enjoy the following great benefits:

What's Included

  • Free access to 4 subscriber-only articles per month

  • Email newsletter providing advice and guidance across the sector

Register

Already have an account? Sign in here


More like this

Hertfordshire Youth Workers

“Opportunities in districts teams and countywide”

Administration Apprentice

SE1 7JY, London (Greater)