Debate: Should there be voluntary accreditation for childcare?

NO - Jean Birtles, director, Top Notch Nannies

When nannies come to our agency we do an in-depth interview, follow up references, check qualifications and do a police check for each potential nanny. I cannot believe a government body would have the teeth to do the same. I do think the current system works well, especially now that we've got Criminal Records Bureau checks. And I think that if there are to be any changes it should go across the board - not just on a voluntary basis.

NO - Tricia Pritchard, professional officer, Professional Association of Nursery Nurses

I'm opposed to what amounts to a watering down of the system. This would open the door to suspect carers who cannot reach more stringent registration and qualification requirements. The mere mention of a "light touch" would be music to the ears of someone who knew they might not scrape through rigorous inspection. When we set high standards and minimum standards we should all stick to them. In fact, this makes me question the Government's commitment to a quality workforce.