Letters to the Editor: X-ray pilot raises complex issues

We are concerned that there has been no consultation process with social care, health or legal professionals about the dental X-ray pilot scheme (‘X-ray pilot for child asylum-seekers sparks outrage’, cypnow.co.uk, 29 March).

A perfunctory announcement the day before the trial began demonstrates the government’s complete lack of awareness of the complex issues this pilot raises.

The government claims this will be a voluntary process, but how confident will these vulnerable children feel in reality to object to the process, particularly if they are unable to speak English?

Social workers need the time to build relationships with unaccompanied minors to help ascertain their age, and their legal entitle-ment, rather than a scientific model.

Whether this process is abusive, both from a children’s rights perspective and also through scientific harm experienced by radiation, has to be considered.

The Enforcement Instructions and Guidance issued by the Home Office states it is not the current policy of the Border and Immigration Agency to commission medical reports as part of its age assessment process. What happened to overrule this? We feel that social workers will feel uncomfortable with this new process.

Sue Kent and Nushra Mansuri, British Association of Social Workers

ISA remains safeguarding force

In his article on 20 March, Sir Paul Ennals refers to the government’s decision in June 2010 to halt parts of the Vetting and Barring Scheme (VBS) and states that the Independent Safeguarding Authority (ISA) has been “treading water since then”.

This is not the case. The ISA continues to make independent barring decisions, and employers, local authorities and professional regulators are still under a duty to refer information to the ISA if they believe an individual has harmed or poses a risk of harm to children or vulnerable adults. The ISA also continues to maintain the Children’s Barred List and the Adults Barred List – deciding who should be added to or removed. In addition, the ISA’s first piece of research will shortly be published which will be a contribution to safer recruitment practices.

Amendments to the Safe-guarding Vulnerable Groups Act (2006) are contained within the Protection of Freedoms Bill going through parliament. Until the legislation is changed, the ISA will continue to deliver its essential work in helping to safeguard children and vulnerable adults.

Adrian McAllister, chief executive, Independent Safeguarding Authority