Lessons from Serious Case Reviews: Teenagers


The NSPCC has analysed evidence from serious case reviews to identify learning. This issue summarises the lessons for working with teenagers and the vulnerabilities they can face.

Published case reviews highlight that professionals sometimes struggle to work with challenging teenagers. They are often viewed as independent young people, capable of looking after themselves and able to make their own choices and decisions.

This means professional intervention focuses too often on tackling problem behaviour, rather than recognising that they are children in need of protection.

The learning from these reviews highlights that professionals need to listen to teenagers, but also be able to balance the young person's wishes with their best interests. Intervention needs to be timely and appropriate.

Reasons case reviews were commissioned

This briefing is based on learning from case reviews published between 2010 and March 2014, where teenagers were the subject of the review.

The teenagers in these case reviews faced a complex and wide range of risk factors. They became the subject of reviews following:

  • Suicide or attempted suicide, often following years of abuse or neglect
  • Physical injuries or death at the hands of other young people/partners
  • Sexual exploitation
  • Accidental overdose
  • This briefing does not cover teenage parents.

Risk factors for teenagers in case reviews

Problems at home or within the family

Problems at home or within the family make children vulnerable to abuse, and these are a common factor in case reviews involving teenagers. Issues include:

  • Long history of parental neglect and abuse
    Chronic neglect and abuse during childhood has a long-lasting and significant impact on young people's development and mental health.
  • Bereavement
    Death of a sibling or parent has a profound and lasting impact on young people and their families.
  • Volatile family relationships
    Cycles of familial reconciliation and rejection have a significant impact on young people's wellbeing and mental health.
  • Emotional and mental health issues
    Young people's emotional and mental health problems, developmental delay and attachment issues make them vulnerable to abuse.

Problems at school

Problems at school are another common factor in case reviews involving teenagers. Issues include:

  • Bullying at school or within the community
    Many of these young people experienced bullying at school or within the community, often in addition to abuse at home.
  • Poor educational attendance or achievement
    Poor attendance records and/or disruptive behaviour prevent young people from participating in mainstream education and reduce the likelihood of them gaining formal qualifications

Risky teenage behaviour

The risky behaviour of teenagers is often not considered as a potential indicator of child abuse. Intervention tends to focus on tackling the problematic behaviour, rather than looking at the reasons for it. Issues include:

  • Underage sexual activity
    Teenagers who are sexually active from a young age are at risk of sexual exploitation. Both professionals, and often the young people themselves, viewed this behaviour as a "lifestyle choice", rather than recognising it as a potential indicator of abuse or exploitation.
  • Drug and alcohol misuse
    Tackling young people's substance misuse sometimes becomes the focus of professional intervention, rather than seeing substance misuse as possible indicators of abuse or exploitation.
  • Challenging and criminal behaviour
    Young people's challenging and criminal behaviour overshadows their vulnerabilities, leading to professionals treating them principally as perpetrators of antisocial activity, as opposed to children in need.
  • Self-harm and suicide ideation
    Young people's disclosure of suicidal thoughts and self-harm are not always taken seriously, and are often seen as attention-seeking behaviour as opposed to cries for help.

Previous involvement with agencies

Teenagers often have a history of involvement with statutory agencies. Adolescents subject to case reviews, and their families, have often been known to services for several years. Issues include:

  • History of care
    Many of the young people in these case reviews spent periods of time in care, often in multiple placements. This led to a lack of stability and the absence of adults willing or able to defend young people's best interests.
  • Periods of homelessness
    Many of these young people were homeless for periods of time. Accommodation that is provided to homeless teenagers is often not appropriate to the young person's needs, either because it does not provide the support or the safety that they need, or they are unable to stick to the rules resulting in them leaving, which increases their vulnerability further.
  • Victims of domestic abuse
    Girls in abusive relationships are sometimes treated as adult victims of domestic violence, rather than being seen as victims of child abuse.
  • Involvement with multiple agencies
    Teenagers with long-standing and complex problems often receive a wide range of different services from different agencies. This can mean that there is no overall picture of the young person's situation.

Learning for improved practice

Listening to what young people are trying to say

Teenagers can find it difficult to articulate and explain their thoughts and feelings. Professionals should:

  • Take disclosure of abuse, self-harm and suicidal thoughts seriously
    Young people need to be listened to, so teenagers who disclose abuse, self-harm or suicidal thoughts should be taken seriously and their disclosure acted upon accordingly. Retractions should not be taken more seriously than accusations.
  • Ensure that the lead practitioner knows the child
    Multi-agency responses should be coordinated by a lead practitioner who has built up a relationship with the child.
  • Provide an advocate to represent the child's best interests
    Young people should be provided with an advocate to explain their rights and represent their best interests.
  • Recognise self-harm or suicide incidents as child protection issues
    Incidents involving self-harm or suicide should be treated as child protection as well as mental health issues. Young people should not be discharged from hospital following a suicide attempt without an assessment of their child protection needs.
  • Balance a child's wishes against their best interests
    Despite the apparent independence and maturity of some young people, professionals should not be too quick to act in accordance with a young person's expressed wishes. In some cases, these wishes are in direct conflict with their best interests.

Keeping the focus on young people

Professionals should always bear in mind that adolescents are still children in need of support and protection. They should:

  • Treat 16- and 17-year-olds as children in need
    Young people aged 16 and 17 are still children, and need the same level of support as younger children.
  • Help young people access services
    Failure to attend appointments should not be equated with a lack of desire to receive support, and may reflect the chaotic lifestyles some vulnerable young people lead. Cases should not be closed purely on the strength of poor attendance. Professionals should persevere to ensure that young people receive the services they need.
  • Consider causes of risky and challenging behaviour
    Professionals should consider the causes of young people's risky and challenging behaviour, rather than focusing on the behaviours themselves.
  • Update chronologies
    All agencies should be aware of, and continue to add to the young person's chronology. Agencies should be aware of and reflect on the impact long-term abuse and neglect has on the young people involved to ensure that the appropriate level of support is provided.

Providing early and age-appropriate services

Services need to be suitable and appropriate to ensure they are effective in helping to keep young people safe from harm. Considerations include:

  • Provide early intervention
    Interventions should take place as early as possible. Young people should not be exposed to long term, ongoing abuse and neglect.
  • Provide appropriate accommodation and placements
    Teenagers taken into care should be placed in accommodation appropriate to their age and needs. In cases where they were subject to a child protection plan before being taken into care, families should be assessed for child protection concerns before young people can return home.
  • Provide appropriate sexual health services
    When an underage girl requests contraception it should prompt a full assessment of social circumstances and risk of sexual exploitation. Assessments of sexual activity should reflect on a girl's emotional and intellectual maturity as opposed to just their level of understanding of the treatment (i.e. contraception).

FURTHER READING

Risk-taking Adolescents and Child Protection, Strategic Briefing, Research in Practice, March 2014

Learning From Case Reviews - Suicide Ideation, NSPCC, 2014

Safeguarding Young People: Responding to 11- to 17-Year-Olds who are maltreated, NSPCC and The Children's Society, 2010

CYP Now Digital membership

  • Policy and research analysis
  • Evidence-based case studies
  • Leadership advice
  • Legal updates
  • Local area spotlights

From £170 /year

Subscribe

CYP Now Magazine

  • Policy and research analysis
  • Evidence-based case studies
  • Leadership advice and interviews
  • Legal updates

From £136 /year

Subscribe