The Conservative Party's Social Justice Policy Group has called for a V Card programme where disengaged young people would earn credits for community work, which could then be exchanged for financial rewards.

YES - Iain Duncan Smith, head, Social Justice Policy Group

We need to show young people that there's a balance and that if they're doing something positive then their society will reward them. There are organisations that have already tried this and it can help young people get started and give them an incentive to get into the habit. I'm in favour of anything that gets young people into volunteering.

NO - Kathy Golding, 19, Kent

Young people shouldn't be paid to volunteer. As someone who has volunteered in the past, I think it is really important to thank young people for their contribution and so the V Card is a good idea.But I don't think it is right to volunteer for money because that seems to defeat the purpose. A small reward - even a certificate that recognises the skills they've gained - would be just as motivational.The skills I got from doing something different and the opportunity to help were the main things that made me want to volunteer.

NO - Joanna Theodoulou, v20 advisory board member, 20, London

Volunteering for financial benefit is a silent bribe and that's not genuine volunteering. It should be all about benefiting the community, and the 'rewards' are all about making a difference, meeting new people, learning new skills for life and gaining a positive experience. Recognition is always great, and that's something I'd definitely encourage. Having someone from the organisation I'm supporting say a simple thank you means so much - I know my efforts are worthwhile.

YES - Vanessa Yannick, 18, Brixton

Volunteering is good because it's something for young people to do. There's nothing much out there for young people and volunteering would give young people an opportunity to make friends. As long as there is something in it for young people then it will keep them focused.