Channel 4 show is 'abusive', says Cornwall safeguarding board
By Shafik Meghji Friday, 13 February 2009
Cornwall's assistant children's director has written to Channel 4 to express "extreme disquiet" with a documentary that filmed boys and girls left alone in a village in the county.
Boys and Girls Alone demeans and "to some extent demonises" the children involved, some of whom are likely to suffer from long-term consequences as a result, the letter said. In the programme, 20 primary school children are left without adult supervision for two weeks.
Writing on behalf of the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Local Safeguarding Children Board, Ruby Parry, assistant director of children, young people and families of Cornwall's Children's Services Authority, said: "While only one programme has so far been broadcast, some of the children were greatly distressed and this in our view is abusive.
"This distress has now been publicly broadcast to all of these children's peers, and is therefore likely to have long-term consequences for some of them."
The letter suggests the programme-makers may have breached the Performance Licensing Legislation (PLL), and added the board was considering legal options.
A spokesman for Channel 4 said the broadcaster had fully complied with all the appropriate child safety legislation, adding the PLL did not apply to factual programmes.
Andrew Mackenzie, Channel 4's head of factual entertainment, said: "All the children were carefully chosen and screened by appropriately qualified experts, including a clinical psychologist, to make sure they could cope well with the experience of being in the series.
"The children and their parents also had access to expert advice and support at all stages of production and after broadcast. The children lived in a protected environment with around-the-clock security during production."
Related Articles
Would you like to post a comment?
Additional Information
Latest jobs Jobs web feed
- Service Manager Catch 22 Up to £32,738, Wolverhampton
- Project Workers Catch 22 Up to £23,762, Wolverhampton
- Contract and Performance Manager Woking YMCA £27,000 per annum pro rata, Woking with travel across Surrey
- Senior Practitioner 1625 Independent People Qualified: £26,276 - £28,636, Bristol and surrounding area
- 3 Project Workers (Mental Health, Accommodation, Learning and Work) 1625 Independent People Various £21,519 and £27,852, Bristol and surrounding area
Most read
- BBC social work film prompts calls for early police support
- YMCA hostel closure to leave 250 young people without housing
- Government urged to address disparate uptake of free childcare
- Social impact bonds to fund intensive therapy in Essex
- Government adviser voices fears over benefits cap
- Teachers report lack of toilet training among children
Most commented
- BBC social work film prompts calls for early police support
- Political parties urged to back loan scheme for childcare
- Government urged to address disparate uptake of free childcare
- Ask the Expert: How to deal with young crushes
- Liverpool council takes reins on Youth Contract delivery
- Young Devon struggles with spike in demand




